{"generated_at":"2026-09-29T19:29:44Z","synthetic":false,"artist":"caroline","slug":"caroline","reference":{"basis":"in-sample","path":null,"label":"album tracks across 13112 albums","generated_at":"2026-09-29T19:29:44Z","n_albums":13112,"n_eligible":96199,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"standout_pct":0.95,"notable_pct":0.8,"base_rates":{"n_albums":10930,"leaders_above_95":0.2937,"random_best_above_95":0.3364,"clear":0.0957}},"model":{"n_tracks":158208,"r2":0.895,"r2_within":0.254,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"coefficients":{"log_listeners":0.0995,"position":-0.0203,"is_single":0.0637,"log_duration":0.0511},"listener_floor":0.2,"min_listeners":1000,"gate_alpha":0.05,"leading_alpha":0.2,"description":"log(plays per listener) regressed on log_listeners, position, is_single, log_duration and an album fixed effect, fitted by least squares across all albums, skits excluded."},"shape":{"n_albums":2,"n_placed":16,"cells":{"deep":2,"anthem":6,"passed":2,"rest":6},"shares":{"deep":0.125,"anthem":0.375,"passed":0.125,"rest":0.375}},"catalogue_albums":2,"corpus_shape":{"n_albums":10907,"n_placed":128167,"cells":{"deep":18992,"anthem":47424,"passed":19015,"rest":42736},"shares":{"deep":0.1482,"anthem":0.37,"passed":0.1484,"rest":0.3334}},"albums":[{"slug":"caroline--caroline-2","artist":"caroline","title":"caroline 2","year":2025,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/caroline+2","min_listeners":7223,"gate_dcae":1.988,"leader":"U R UR ONLY ACHING","evidence":"none","null_share":0.8164,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"U R UR ONLY ACHING","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2025-05-30","list_sources":["pitchfork","aoty","stereogum"],"group":"critical","album_listeners":83605,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"caroline 2","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.666,"least_reached":"Beautiful ending","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.432,"median_ppl":3.887,"cells":{"deep":2,"anthem":2,"passed":2,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"U R UR ONLY ACHING","position":5,"ppl":3.946,"ppl_vs_album":1.015,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Total euphoria","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":270,"listeners":66788,"playcount":301312,"ppl":4.511,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.37,"ratio":1.032,"dcae":0.653,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7989,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/total+euphoria","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.161,"reach_vs_album":1.849,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9692,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400262"},{"position":2,"name":"Song two","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":212,"listeners":40654,"playcount":154110,"ppl":3.791,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.843,"ratio":0.986,"dcae":-0.281,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4863,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Song+two","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.975,"reach_vs_album":1.126,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4711,"reach_pct":0.8696,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400263"},{"position":3,"name":"Tell me I never knew that","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":279,"listeners":100587,"playcount":461709,"ppl":4.59,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.533,"ratio":1.013,"dcae":0.258,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.2031,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Tell+me+I+never+knew+that","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.181,"reach_vs_album":2.785,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9907,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400264"},{"position":4,"name":"When I get home","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":366,"listeners":34934,"playcount":132985,"ppl":3.807,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.87,"ratio":0.984,"dcae":-0.338,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4178,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/When+I+get+home","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.979,"reach_vs_album":0.967,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4633,"reach_pct":0.8142,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400265"},{"position":5,"name":"U R UR ONLY ACHING","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":278,"listeners":31651,"playcount":124898,"ppl":3.946,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.768,"ratio":1.047,"dcae":0.945,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.3786,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/U+R+UR+ONLY+ACHING","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.015,"reach_vs_album":0.876,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.6972,"reach_pct":0.7702,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400266"},{"position":6,"name":"Coldplay cover","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":256,"listeners":37301,"playcount":144926,"ppl":3.885,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.803,"ratio":1.022,"dcae":0.438,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4462,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Coldplay+cover","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.999,"reach_vs_album":1.033,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6148,"reach_pct":0.8399,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400267"},{"position":7,"name":"Two riders down","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":399,"listeners":29289,"playcount":113907,"ppl":3.889,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.787,"ratio":1.027,"dcae":0.546,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3503,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Two+riders+down","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.001,"reach_vs_album":0.811,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6325,"reach_pct":0.732,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400268"},{"position":8,"name":"Beautiful ending","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline 2","seconds":325,"listeners":27273,"playcount":90774,"ppl":3.328,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.71,"ratio":0.897,"dcae":-2.221,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3262,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Beautiful+ending","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.856,"reach_vs_album":0.755,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1678,"reach_pct":0.6945,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBCVZ2400269"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"2025","mb_release_group":"52089578-57af-48be-8ee8-594db56a91ed","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"caroline--caroline","artist":"caroline","title":"caroline","year":2022,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/Caroline","min_listeners":3882,"gate_dcae":2.033,"leader":"IWR","evidence":"leading","null_share":0.0595,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"IWR","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2022-02-25","list_sources":["crate:caroline"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"caroline","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":76319,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"caroline","sleeper_hits":null,"depth":null,"least_reached":"zilch","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.25435,"median_ppl":3.504,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":4,"passed":0,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Dark blue","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":396,"listeners":53464,"playcount":206412,"ppl":3.861,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.939,"ratio":0.98,"dcae":-0.3,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7005,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Dark+blue","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.102,"reach_vs_album":2.754,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4466,"reach_pct":0.9527,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":2,"name":"Good morning (red)","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":347,"listeners":58257,"playcount":233780,"ppl":4.013,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.937,"ratio":1.019,"dcae":0.285,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7633,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Good+morning+(red)","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.145,"reach_vs_album":3.001,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6029,"reach_pct":0.964,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":3,"name":"desperately","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":73,"listeners":25409,"playcount":86809,"ppl":3.416,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"73s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.34,"ratio":1.023,"dcae":0.338,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3329,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/desperately","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7051,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":4,"name":"IWR","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":389,"listeners":26154,"playcount":108871,"ppl":4.163,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.64,"ratio":1.143,"dcae":2.005,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.3427,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/IWR","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.188,"reach_vs_album":1.347,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8808,"reach_pct":0.7205,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":5,"name":"messen #7","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":100,"listeners":19084,"playcount":63605,"ppl":3.333,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.284,"ratio":1.015,"dcae":0.221,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2501,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/messen+%237","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.951,"reach_vs_album":0.983,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5885,"reach_pct":0.5493,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":6,"name":"Engine (eavesdropping)","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":342,"listeners":17869,"playcount":60403,"ppl":3.38,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.466,"ratio":0.975,"dcae":-0.376,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2341,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Engine+(eavesdropping)","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.965,"reach_vs_album":0.92,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4255,"reach_pct":0.515,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":7,"name":"hurtle","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":50,"listeners":16793,"playcount":52497,"ppl":3.126,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"50s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.116,"ratio":1.003,"dcae":0.05,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.22,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/hurtle","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.4835,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":8,"name":"Skydiving onto the library roof","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":462,"listeners":19737,"playcount":71596,"ppl":3.628,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.539,"ratio":1.025,"dcae":0.369,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2586,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Skydiving+onto+the+library+roof","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.035,"reach_vs_album":1.017,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6254,"reach_pct":0.5677,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":9,"name":"zilch","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":128,"listeners":15095,"playcount":45653,"ppl":3.024,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.22,"ratio":0.939,"dcae":-0.937,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1978,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/zilch","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.863,"reach_vs_album":0.778,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2884,"reach_pct":0.4313,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":10,"name":"Natural death","artist":"caroline","album":"caroline","seconds":520,"listeners":15199,"playcount":48232,"ppl":3.173,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.454,"ratio":0.919,"dcae":-1.266,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1992,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Caroline/_/Natural+death","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.906,"reach_vs_album":0.783,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2241,"reach_pct":0.4347,"featuring":[],"isrc":null}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring3-01","mb_release_group":"517c148b-737e-44d6-a9cd-1fe0a90fcff1","art":true,"release_type":"album"}]}