{"generated_at":"2026-09-29T22:26:54Z","synthetic":false,"artist":"Breaking Benjamin","slug":"breaking-benjamin","reference":{"basis":"in-sample","path":null,"label":"album tracks across 13083 albums","generated_at":"2026-09-29T22:26:54Z","n_albums":13083,"n_eligible":96176,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"standout_pct":0.95,"notable_pct":0.8,"base_rates":{"n_albums":10908,"leaders_above_95":0.2959,"random_best_above_95":0.337,"clear":0.0955}},"model":{"n_tracks":157547,"r2":0.896,"r2_within":0.255,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"coefficients":{"log_listeners":0.1008,"position":-0.0195,"is_single":0.0627,"log_duration":0.051},"listener_floor":0.2,"min_listeners":1000,"gate_alpha":0.05,"leading_alpha":0.2,"description":"log(plays per listener) regressed on log_listeners, position, is_single, log_duration and an album fixed effect, fitted by least squares across all albums, skits excluded."},"shape":{"n_albums":6,"n_placed":68,"cells":{"deep":5,"anthem":30,"passed":5,"rest":28},"shares":{"deep":0.0735,"anthem":0.4412,"passed":0.0735,"rest":0.4118}},"catalogue_albums":8,"corpus_shape":{"n_albums":10900,"n_placed":128048,"cells":{"deep":18961,"anthem":47399,"passed":18986,"rest":42702},"shares":{"deep":0.1481,"anthem":0.3702,"passed":0.1483,"rest":0.3335}},"albums":[{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--saturate","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Saturate","year":2002,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Saturate","min_listeners":30668,"gate_dcae":2.197,"leader":"Home","evidence":"none","null_share":0.9918,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Home","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2002-08-27","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":533002,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Saturate","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.814,"least_reached":"Sugarcoat","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.2877,"median_ppl":6.065,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":5,"passed":1,"rest":5},"deep_cut":{"name":"Water","position":7,"ppl":6.101,"ppl_vs_album":1.006,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Wish I May","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":239,"listeners":156203,"playcount":941762,"ppl":6.029,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.214,"ratio":0.97,"dcae":-0.434,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2931,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Wish+I+May","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.994,"reach_vs_album":1.019,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4047,"reach_pct":0.6365,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220091"},{"position":2,"name":"Medicate","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":226,"listeners":188679,"playcount":1258763,"ppl":6.671,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.712,"ratio":0.994,"dcae":-0.088,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.354,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Medicate","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.1,"reach_vs_album":1.23,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7374,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220089"},{"position":3,"name":"Polyamorous","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":178,"listeners":289659,"playcount":2147736,"ppl":7.415,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.912,"ratio":1.073,"dcae":1.009,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5434,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Polyamorous","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.223,"reach_vs_album":1.889,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9007,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220046"},{"position":4,"name":"Skin","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":201,"listeners":189077,"playcount":1161329,"ppl":6.142,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.65,"ratio":0.924,"dcae":-1.143,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3547,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Skin","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.013,"reach_vs_album":1.233,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7382,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220092"},{"position":5,"name":"Natural Life","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":240,"listeners":147683,"playcount":864293,"ppl":5.852,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.137,"ratio":0.954,"dcae":-0.682,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2771,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Natural+Life","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.965,"reach_vs_album":0.963,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3432,"reach_pct":0.6058,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220093"},{"position":6,"name":"Next to Nothing","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":224,"listeners":157044,"playcount":976656,"ppl":6.219,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.142,"ratio":1.013,"dcae":0.179,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2946,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Next+To+Nothing","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.025,"reach_vs_album":1.024,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5805,"reach_pct":0.6394,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220094"},{"position":7,"name":"Water","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":253,"listeners":150484,"playcount":918065,"ppl":6.101,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.143,"ratio":0.993,"dcae":-0.099,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2823,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Water","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.006,"reach_vs_album":0.981,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.4998,"reach_pct":0.6161,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220095"},{"position":8,"name":"Home","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":218,"listeners":164254,"playcount":1038122,"ppl":6.32,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.14,"ratio":1.029,"dcae":0.416,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.3082,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Home","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.042,"reach_vs_album":1.071,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6398,"reach_pct":0.6638,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220096"},{"position":9,"name":"Phase","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":271,"listeners":135337,"playcount":779612,"ppl":5.761,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.077,"ratio":0.948,"dcae":-0.77,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2539,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Phase","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.95,"reach_vs_album":0.883,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3205,"reach_pct":0.5576,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220098"},{"position":10,"name":"No Games","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":216,"listeners":148690,"playcount":855780,"ppl":5.755,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.054,"ratio":0.951,"dcae":-0.727,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.279,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/No+Games","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.949,"reach_vs_album":0.97,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3317,"reach_pct":0.6094,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220099"},{"position":11,"name":"Sugarcoat","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":219,"listeners":134295,"playcount":790826,"ppl":5.889,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.986,"ratio":0.984,"dcae":-0.235,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.252,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Sugarcoat","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.971,"reach_vs_album":0.876,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4633,"reach_pct":0.5534,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220100"},{"position":12,"name":"Shallow Bay / Forever","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Saturate","seconds":482,"listeners":984,"playcount":4460,"ppl":4.533,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.789,"ratio":1.196,"dcae":2.573,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.0018,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Shallow+Bay+%2F+Forever","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.747,"reach_vs_album":0.006,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.0,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220101"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"5a4bfa4c-1baa-39fa-ac93-c0063cc60b7f","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--we-are-not-alone","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"We Are Not Alone","year":2004,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/We+Are+Not+Alone","min_listeners":48131,"gate_dcae":2.107,"leader":"Breakdown","evidence":"none","null_share":0.9771,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Firefly","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2004-06-29","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":848659,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"We Are Not Alone","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Firefly","position":4,"listeners":325360,"singles_out_reached":3},{"name":"Break My Fall","position":5,"listeners":240656,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Breakdown","position":8,"listeners":238348,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Away","position":9,"listeners":226407,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Simple Design","position":2,"listeners":204574,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Believe","position":10,"listeners":194019,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.785,"least_reached":"Believe","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.2836,"median_ppl":6.852,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":5,"passed":1,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"So Cold","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":273,"listeners":597554,"playcount":4362759,"ppl":7.301,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.891,"ratio":0.925,"dcae":-1.203,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7041,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/So+Cold","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.066,"reach_vs_album":2.483,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9534,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421070"},{"position":2,"name":"Simple Design","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":255,"listeners":204574,"playcount":1330485,"ppl":6.504,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.616,"ratio":0.983,"dcae":-0.265,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2411,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Simple+Design","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.949,"reach_vs_album":0.85,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4592,"reach_pct":0.5299,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421017"},{"position":3,"name":"Follow","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":198,"listeners":186242,"playcount":1480388,"ppl":7.949,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.875,"ratio":1.156,"dcae":2.245,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2195,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Follow","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.16,"reach_vs_album":0.774,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.4821,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421018"},{"position":4,"name":"Firefly","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":188,"listeners":325360,"playcount":2241323,"ppl":6.889,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.799,"ratio":1.013,"dcae":0.202,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.3834,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Firefly","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.005,"reach_vs_album":1.352,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5805,"reach_pct":0.7761,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421019"},{"position":5,"name":"Break My Fall","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":205,"listeners":240656,"playcount":1497236,"ppl":6.221,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.612,"ratio":0.941,"dcae":-0.942,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2836,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Break+My+Fall","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.908,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2951,"reach_pct":0.6186,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421020"},{"position":6,"name":"Forget It","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":218,"listeners":291409,"playcount":2253222,"ppl":7.732,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.186,"ratio":1.076,"dcae":1.134,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3434,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Forget+It","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.128,"reach_vs_album":1.211,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7216,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421021"},{"position":7,"name":"Sooner or Later","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":219,"listeners":340990,"playcount":2393644,"ppl":7.02,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.288,"ratio":0.963,"dcae":-0.581,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4018,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Sooner+Or+Later","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.025,"reach_vs_album":1.417,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7972,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421432"},{"position":8,"name":"Breakdown","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":216,"listeners":238348,"playcount":1600415,"ppl":6.715,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.585,"ratio":1.02,"dcae":0.302,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2809,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Breakdown","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.98,"reach_vs_album":0.99,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6071,"reach_pct":0.6133,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421003"},{"position":9,"name":"Away","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":192,"listeners":226407,"playcount":1499973,"ppl":6.625,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.499,"ratio":1.019,"dcae":0.298,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2668,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Away","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.967,"reach_vs_album":0.941,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6032,"reach_pct":0.5845,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421004"},{"position":10,"name":"Believe","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":200,"listeners":194019,"playcount":1191586,"ppl":6.142,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.399,"ratio":0.96,"dcae":-0.636,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2286,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Believe","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.896,"reach_vs_album":0.806,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3656,"reach_pct":0.5025,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421005"},{"position":11,"name":"Rain","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"We Are Not Alone","seconds":207,"listeners":293057,"playcount":2007891,"ppl":6.852,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.101,"ratio":0.965,"dcae":-0.554,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3453,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Rain","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":1.218,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7244,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421086"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"9a03d313-0580-3f71-ae10-0e0996db3faa","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--so-cold-ep","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"So Cold EP","year":2004,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/So+Cold+EP","min_listeners":7744,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Blow Me Away","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2004-11-23","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":true,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":83936,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"So Cold EP","sleeper_hits":null,"depth":null,"least_reached":"Breakdown (live)","grid":"few_tracks","median_reach":null,"median_ppl":null,"cells":null,"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"So Cold (acoustic)","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"So Cold EP","seconds":235,"listeners":43558,"playcount":325554,"ppl":7.474,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"possible undercount: Last.fm's bigger 'So Cold' was judged a different recording","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.324,"ratio":1.182,"dcae":0.982,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5189,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/So+Cold+(acoustic)","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8886,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421367"},{"position":2,"name":"Blow Me Away","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"So Cold EP","seconds":206,"listeners":284937,"playcount":2712950,"ppl":9.521,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.555,"ratio":1.26,"dcae":1.36,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":3.3947,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Blow+Me+Away","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.957,"reach_pct":0.998,"featuring":["Valora"],"isrc":"USHR10421403"},{"position":3,"name":"Lady Bug","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"So Cold EP","seconds":183,"listeners":38721,"playcount":242170,"ppl":6.254,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.111,"ratio":1.024,"dcae":0.137,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4613,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Lady+Bug","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6221,"reach_pct":0.8519,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10220191"},{"position":4,"name":"Away (live)","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"So Cold EP","seconds":204,"listeners":20405,"playcount":104328,"ppl":5.113,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.732,"ratio":0.892,"dcae":-0.672,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2431,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Away+%5BLive%5D","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1566,"reach_pct":0.5339,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421236"},{"position":5,"name":"Breakdown (live)","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"So Cold EP","seconds":224,"listeners":19291,"playcount":95554,"ppl":4.953,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.699,"ratio":0.869,"dcae":-0.825,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2298,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Breakdown+%5BLive%5D","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1149,"reach_pct":0.5053,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10421404"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"226745b4-c82c-398b-ae1d-88d6051a563a","art":true,"release_type":"ep"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--phobia","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Phobia","year":2006,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Phobia","min_listeners":85663,"gate_dcae":2.197,"leader":"Evil Angel","evidence":"none","null_share":0.9977,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Evil Angel","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2006-08-08","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":1456858,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Phobia","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Dance With the Devil","position":7,"listeners":672621,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.726,"least_reached":"Outro","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.3054,"median_ppl":6.721,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":6,"passed":0,"rest":6},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Intro","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":74,"listeners":233232,"playcount":1201360,"ppl":5.151,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"74s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.201,"ratio":0.831,"dcae":-1.942,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1601,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Intro","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.3392,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622230"},{"position":2,"name":"The Diary of Jane","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":201,"listeners":930207,"playcount":8124995,"ppl":8.735,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.975,"ratio":1.095,"dcae":0.952,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6385,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/The+Diary+of+Jane","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.3,"reach_vs_album":2.091,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9366,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622153"},{"position":3,"name":"Breath","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":218,"listeners":905820,"playcount":8363128,"ppl":9.233,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.974,"ratio":1.158,"dcae":1.534,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6218,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Breath","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.374,"reach_vs_album":2.036,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9316,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622219"},{"position":4,"name":"You","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":202,"listeners":428318,"playcount":2786029,"ppl":6.505,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.906,"ratio":0.942,"dcae":-0.627,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.294,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/You","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.968,"reach_vs_album":0.963,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2991,"reach_pct":0.6384,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622224"},{"position":5,"name":"Evil Angel","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":221,"listeners":481330,"playcount":3452742,"ppl":7.173,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.008,"ratio":1.024,"dcae":0.243,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.3304,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Evil+Angel","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.067,"reach_vs_album":1.082,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6221,"reach_pct":0.7011,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622223"},{"position":6,"name":"Until the End","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":253,"listeners":540255,"playcount":3822686,"ppl":7.076,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.59,"ratio":0.932,"dcae":-0.734,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3708,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Until+The+End","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.053,"reach_vs_album":1.214,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7605,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622221"},{"position":7,"name":"Dance With the Devil","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":227,"listeners":672621,"playcount":5799892,"ppl":8.623,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.235,"ratio":1.192,"dcae":1.836,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4617,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dance+With+The+Devil","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.283,"reach_vs_album":1.512,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8523,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622232"},{"position":8,"name":"Topless","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":183,"listeners":364294,"playcount":2238717,"ppl":6.145,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.716,"ratio":0.915,"dcae":-0.93,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2501,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Topless","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.914,"reach_vs_album":0.819,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2135,"reach_pct":0.549,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622226"},{"position":9,"name":"Here We Are","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":259,"listeners":292453,"playcount":1918257,"ppl":6.559,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.676,"ratio":0.983,"dcae":-0.184,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2007,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Here+We+Are","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.976,"reach_vs_album":0.657,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4592,"reach_pct":0.4381,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622225"},{"position":10,"name":"Unknown Soldier","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":226,"listeners":354894,"playcount":2310916,"ppl":6.512,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.749,"ratio":0.965,"dcae":-0.375,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2436,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Unknown+Soldier","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.969,"reach_vs_album":0.798,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3848,"reach_pct":0.535,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622222"},{"position":11,"name":"Had Enough","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":230,"listeners":461564,"playcount":3176784,"ppl":6.883,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.925,"ratio":0.994,"dcae":-0.065,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3168,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Had+Enough","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.024,"reach_vs_album":1.037,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5037,"reach_pct":0.6792,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622227"},{"position":12,"name":"You Fight Me","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":193,"listeners":270186,"playcount":1732838,"ppl":6.414,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.492,"ratio":0.988,"dcae":-0.128,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1855,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/You+Fight+Me","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.954,"reach_vs_album":0.607,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4794,"reach_pct":0.4013,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622228"},{"position":13,"name":"Outro","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Phobia","seconds":129,"listeners":198898,"playcount":1058707,"ppl":5.323,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.157,"ratio":0.865,"dcae":-1.523,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1365,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Outro","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.792,"reach_vs_album":0.447,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1086,"reach_pct":0.2816,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10622231"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"79f338ee-d67c-3845-945c-1fd2e03e8f1b","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--dear-agony","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Dear Agony","year":2009,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Dear+Agony","min_listeners":35289,"gate_dcae":2.107,"leader":"Without You","evidence":"none","null_share":0.7064,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Without You","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2009-09-29","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":780657,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Dear Agony","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Dear Agony","position":9,"listeners":266019,"singles_out_reached":3},{"name":"Without You","position":11,"listeners":210084,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"Crawl","position":3,"listeners":208775,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"What Lies Beneath","position":6,"listeners":176445,"singles_out_reached":2}],"depth":0.831,"least_reached":"Into the Nothing","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.226,"median_ppl":8.725,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":5,"passed":1,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Fade Away","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":196,"listeners":172328,"playcount":1449512,"ppl":8.411,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.304,"ratio":1.013,"dcae":0.212,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2207,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Fade+Away","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.964,"reach_vs_album":0.977,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5805,"reach_pct":0.4849,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924585"},{"position":2,"name":"I Will Not Bow","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":217,"listeners":601326,"playcount":5288354,"ppl":8.794,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":10.061,"ratio":0.874,"dcae":-2.224,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7703,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/I+Will+Not+Bow","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.008,"reach_vs_album":3.408,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9651,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924529"},{"position":3,"name":"Crawl","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":239,"listeners":208775,"playcount":1723428,"ppl":8.255,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.519,"ratio":0.969,"dcae":-0.52,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2674,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Crawl","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.946,"reach_vs_album":1.183,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4008,"reach_pct":0.5857,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924586"},{"position":4,"name":"Give Me a Sign","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":258,"listeners":252531,"playcount":2329244,"ppl":9.224,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":9.264,"ratio":0.996,"dcae":-0.073,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3235,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Give+Me+a+Sign","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.057,"reach_vs_album":1.431,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.6904,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924587"},{"position":5,"name":"Hopeless","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":200,"listeners":159155,"playcount":1324004,"ppl":8.319,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.182,"ratio":1.017,"dcae":0.274,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2039,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Hopeless","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.953,"reach_vs_album":0.902,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5956,"reach_pct":0.4459,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924588"},{"position":6,"name":"What Lies Beneath","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":215,"listeners":176445,"playcount":1539542,"ppl":8.725,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.282,"ratio":1.054,"dcae":0.862,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.226,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/What+Lies+Beneath","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.718,"reach_pct":0.4966,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924589"},{"position":7,"name":"Anthem of the Angels","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":243,"listeners":162594,"playcount":1432625,"ppl":8.811,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.784,"ratio":1.003,"dcae":0.052,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2083,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Anthem+Of+The+Angels","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.01,"reach_vs_album":0.922,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.4562,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924590"},{"position":8,"name":"Lights Out","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":214,"listeners":161030,"playcount":1307385,"ppl":8.119,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.701,"ratio":0.933,"dcae":-1.145,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2063,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Lights+Out","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.931,"reach_vs_album":0.913,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.4516,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924591"},{"position":9,"name":"Dear Agony","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":258,"listeners":266019,"playcount":2476949,"ppl":9.311,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.662,"ratio":1.075,"dcae":1.194,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3408,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dear+Agony","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.067,"reach_vs_album":1.508,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7177,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924592"},{"position":10,"name":"Into the Nothing","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":224,"listeners":147894,"playcount":1220914,"ppl":8.255,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.09,"ratio":1.02,"dcae":0.335,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1894,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Into+The+Nothing","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.946,"reach_vs_album":0.838,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6071,"reach_pct":0.4106,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924593"},{"position":11,"name":"Without You","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dear Agony","seconds":257,"listeners":210084,"playcount":1883771,"ppl":8.967,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":8.424,"ratio":1.064,"dcae":1.032,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.2691,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Without+You","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.028,"reach_vs_album":1.191,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7436,"reach_pct":0.5895,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR10924594"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"984dc287-6af5-458f-80be-4ae6b47147d7","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--dark-before-dawn","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Dark Before Dawn","year":2015,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Dark+Before+Dawn","min_listeners":11881,"gate_dcae":2.138,"leader":"Hollow","evidence":"none","null_share":0.2845,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Hollow","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2015-06-23","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":315169,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Dark Before Dawn","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Hollow","position":5,"listeners":64192,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Close to Heaven","position":6,"listeners":54620,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.55,"least_reached":"The Great Divide","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.1885,"median_ppl":7.616,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":5,"passed":1,"rest":5},"deep_cut":{"name":"Close to Heaven","position":6,"ppl":8.22,"ppl_vs_album":1.079,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Dark","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":130,"listeners":43431,"playcount":232183,"ppl":5.346,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.881,"ratio":0.777,"dcae":-2.427,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1378,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dark","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.702,"reach_vs_album":0.731,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.031,"reach_pct":0.2853,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536292"},{"position":2,"name":"Failure","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":214,"listeners":177777,"playcount":1512535,"ppl":8.508,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.647,"ratio":0.984,"dcae":-0.156,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5641,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Failure","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.117,"reach_vs_album":2.993,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9099,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536289"},{"position":3,"name":"Angels Fall","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":228,"listeners":197157,"playcount":1672498,"ppl":8.483,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.75,"ratio":0.969,"dcae":-0.298,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6256,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Angels+Fall","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.114,"reach_vs_album":3.319,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9329,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536293"},{"position":4,"name":"Breaking the Silence","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":181,"listeners":70917,"playcount":533106,"ppl":7.517,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.787,"ratio":0.965,"dcae":-0.339,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.225,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Breaking+the+Silence","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.987,"reach_vs_album":1.194,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.4943,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536294"},{"position":5,"name":"Hollow","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":231,"listeners":64192,"playcount":554313,"ppl":8.635,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.318,"ratio":1.18,"dcae":1.592,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.2037,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Hollow","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.134,"reach_vs_album":1.081,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.9154,"reach_pct":0.4455,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536295"},{"position":6,"name":"Close to Heaven","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":249,"listeners":54620,"playcount":448991,"ppl":8.22,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.215,"ratio":1.139,"dcae":1.255,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1733,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Close+to+Heaven","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.079,"reach_vs_album":0.919,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.8765,"reach_pct":0.3705,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536296"},{"position":7,"name":"Bury Me Alive","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":244,"listeners":41473,"playcount":296824,"ppl":7.157,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.998,"ratio":1.023,"dcae":0.217,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1316,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Bury+Me+Alive","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.94,"reach_vs_album":0.698,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6186,"reach_pct":0.2693,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536297"},{"position":8,"name":"Never Again","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":223,"listeners":76565,"playcount":590724,"ppl":7.715,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.875,"ratio":0.98,"dcae":-0.198,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2429,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Never+Again","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.013,"reach_vs_album":1.289,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.5336,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536298"},{"position":9,"name":"The Great Divide","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":252,"listeners":40230,"playcount":294692,"ppl":7.325,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.963,"ratio":1.052,"dcae":0.488,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1276,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/The+Great+Divide","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.962,"reach_vs_album":0.677,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7124,"reach_pct":0.2594,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536299"},{"position":10,"name":"Ashes of Eden","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":293,"listeners":101978,"playcount":878518,"ppl":8.615,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.191,"ratio":1.052,"dcae":0.485,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3236,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Ashes+of+Eden","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.131,"reach_vs_album":1.717,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.6905,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536300"},{"position":11,"name":"Defeated","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":205,"listeners":49539,"playcount":361993,"ppl":7.307,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.465,"ratio":0.979,"dcae":-0.206,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1572,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Defeated","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.959,"reach_vs_album":0.834,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.332,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536301"},{"position":12,"name":"Dawn","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Dark Before Dawn","seconds":112,"listeners":43241,"playcount":277278,"ppl":6.412,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.694,"ratio":0.958,"dcae":-0.413,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1372,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dawn","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.842,"reach_vs_album":0.728,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.358,"reach_pct":0.2836,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11536302"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"a6fd8cb6-a2d5-4702-8f12-6bf95a67dcba","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--ember","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Ember","year":2018,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Ember","min_listeners":9848,"gate_dcae":1.905,"leader":"The Dark of You","evidence":"none","null_share":0.2491,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"The Dark of You","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2018-04-13","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":195285,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Ember","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"The Dark of You","position":6,"listeners":58210,"singles_out_reached":4},{"name":"Down","position":7,"listeners":32626,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.55,"least_reached":"Close Your Eyes","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.2852,"median_ppl":7.6485,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":4,"passed":1,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Lyra","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":29,"listeners":10047,"playcount":64373,"ppl":6.407,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"29s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.641,"ratio":1.136,"dcae":2.171,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.0514,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Lyra","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.0776,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738185"},{"position":2,"name":"Feed the Wolf","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":198,"listeners":65417,"playcount":521510,"ppl":7.972,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.989,"ratio":0.998,"dcae":-0.035,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.335,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Feed+the+Wolf","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.042,"reach_vs_album":1.175,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7083,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738186"},{"position":3,"name":"Red Cold River","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":200,"listeners":92689,"playcount":793761,"ppl":8.564,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.264,"ratio":1.036,"dcae":0.608,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4746,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Red+Cold+River","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.12,"reach_vs_album":1.664,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8615,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738189"},{"position":4,"name":"Tourniquet","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":249,"listeners":57466,"playcount":457026,"ppl":7.953,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.949,"ratio":1.0,"dcae":0.008,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2943,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Tourniquet","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.04,"reach_vs_album":1.032,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.6389,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738187"},{"position":5,"name":"Psycho","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":200,"listeners":44579,"playcount":346108,"ppl":7.764,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.649,"ratio":1.015,"dcae":0.255,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2283,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Psycho","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.015,"reach_vs_album":0.8,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.5019,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738188"},{"position":6,"name":"The Dark of You","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":252,"listeners":58210,"playcount":469244,"ppl":8.061,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.454,"ratio":1.081,"dcae":1.336,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.2981,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/The+Dark+of+You","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.054,"reach_vs_album":1.045,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7835,"reach_pct":0.6458,"featuring":["Derek Hough"],"isrc":"USHR11738190"},{"position":7,"name":"Down","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":242,"listeners":32626,"playcount":239516,"ppl":7.341,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":7.004,"ratio":1.048,"dcae":0.801,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1671,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Down","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.96,"reach_vs_album":0.586,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7003,"reach_pct":0.3561,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738191"},{"position":8,"name":"Torn in Two","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":257,"listeners":53910,"playcount":406102,"ppl":7.533,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.855,"ratio":0.959,"dcae":-0.715,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2761,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--aurora"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Torn+in+Two","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.985,"reach_vs_album":0.968,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.604,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738192"},{"position":9,"name":"Blood","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":189,"listeners":131405,"playcount":978364,"ppl":7.445,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.445,"ratio":0.882,"dcae":-2.148,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6729,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Blood","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.973,"reach_vs_album":2.359,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9457,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738193"},{"position":10,"name":"Save Yourself","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":186,"listeners":31968,"playcount":223271,"ppl":6.984,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.304,"ratio":0.956,"dcae":-0.764,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1637,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Save+Yourself","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.913,"reach_vs_album":0.574,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.3478,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738194"},{"position":11,"name":"Close Your Eyes","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":241,"listeners":30062,"playcount":215426,"ppl":7.166,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":6.896,"ratio":1.039,"dcae":0.655,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1539,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Close+Your+Eyes","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.937,"reach_vs_album":0.54,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6731,"reach_pct":0.324,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738195"},{"position":12,"name":"Vega","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Ember","seconds":82,"listeners":22688,"playcount":119140,"ppl":5.251,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"82s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.333,"ratio":0.829,"dcae":-3.195,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1162,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Vega","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.2311,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11738196"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"a244bf4a-6f86-4edc-b441-8c5cd396ecf4","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"breaking-benjamin--aurora","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","title":"Aurora","year":2020,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/Aurora","min_listeners":27046,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":null,"tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2020-01-04","list_sources":["crate:Breaking Benjamin"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Breaking Benjamin","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":71561,"album_listeners_ok":false,"album_listeners_spelling":"Aurora","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Dance With the Devil","position":7,"listeners":672621,"singles_out_reached":4},{"name":"Angels Fall","position":4,"listeners":197157,"singles_out_reached":3},{"name":"Never Again","position":8,"listeners":76565,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Tourniquet","position":6,"listeners":57466,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Torn in Two","position":9,"listeners":53910,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":1.21,"least_reached":null,"grid":"album_count","median_reach":null,"median_ppl":null,"cells":null,"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"So Cold","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":272,"listeners":597554,"playcount":4362759,"ppl":7.301,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":9.093,"ratio":0.803,"dcae":-1.776,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--we-are-not-alone"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/So+Cold","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939375"},{"position":2,"name":"Failure","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":218,"listeners":177777,"playcount":1512535,"ppl":8.508,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.453,"ratio":1.007,"dcae":0.053,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--dark-before-dawn"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Failure","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939380"},{"position":3,"name":"Far Away","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":292,"listeners":38813,"playcount":229028,"ppl":5.901,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.344,"ratio":0.804,"dcae":-1.771,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Far+Away","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":["Scooter Ward"],"isrc":"USHR11939381"},{"position":4,"name":"Angels Fall","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":226,"listeners":197157,"playcount":1672498,"ppl":8.483,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.002,"ratio":1.06,"dcae":0.472,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--dark-before-dawn"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Angels+Fall","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939382"},{"position":5,"name":"Red Cold River","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":199,"listeners":92689,"playcount":793761,"ppl":8.564,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.828,"ratio":1.094,"dcae":0.727,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--ember"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Red+Cold+River","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939383"},{"position":6,"name":"Tourniquet","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":262,"listeners":57466,"playcount":457026,"ppl":7.953,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.09,"ratio":1.122,"dcae":0.93,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--ember"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Tourniquet","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939384"},{"position":7,"name":"Dance With the Devil","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":224,"listeners":672621,"playcount":5799892,"ppl":8.623,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.993,"ratio":0.959,"dcae":-0.341,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--phobia"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dance+With+The+Devil","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939385"},{"position":8,"name":"Never Again","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":222,"listeners":76565,"playcount":590724,"ppl":7.715,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":7.205,"ratio":1.071,"dcae":0.554,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--dark-before-dawn"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Never+Again","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939386"},{"position":9,"name":"Torn in Two","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":245,"listeners":53910,"playcount":406102,"ppl":7.533,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":6.975,"ratio":1.08,"dcae":0.623,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--ember"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Torn+in+Two","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939387"},{"position":10,"name":"Dear Agony","artist":"Breaking Benjamin","album":"Aurora","seconds":256,"listeners":266019,"playcount":2476949,"ppl":9.311,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":8.724,"ratio":1.067,"dcae":0.528,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":["breaking-benjamin--dear-agony"],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Breaking+Benjamin/_/Dear+Agony","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USHR11939388"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"1181d5d3-0a7c-477e-8020-089e7004ae16","art":true,"release_type":"album"}]}