{"generated_at":"2026-09-29T22:26:54Z","synthetic":false,"artist":"Black Sabbath","slug":"black-sabbath","reference":{"basis":"in-sample","path":null,"label":"album tracks across 13083 albums","generated_at":"2026-09-29T22:26:54Z","n_albums":13083,"n_eligible":96176,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"standout_pct":0.95,"notable_pct":0.8,"base_rates":{"n_albums":10908,"leaders_above_95":0.2959,"random_best_above_95":0.337,"clear":0.0955}},"model":{"n_tracks":157547,"r2":0.896,"r2_within":0.255,"features":["log_listeners","position","is_single","log_duration"],"coefficients":{"log_listeners":0.1008,"position":-0.0195,"is_single":0.0627,"log_duration":0.051},"listener_floor":0.2,"min_listeners":1000,"gate_alpha":0.05,"leading_alpha":0.2,"description":"log(plays per listener) regressed on log_listeners, position, is_single, log_duration and an album fixed effect, fitted by least squares across all albums, skits excluded."},"shape":{"n_albums":16,"n_placed":135,"cells":{"deep":15,"anthem":56,"passed":15,"rest":49},"shares":{"deep":0.1111,"anthem":0.4148,"passed":0.1111,"rest":0.363}},"catalogue_albums":19,"corpus_shape":{"n_albums":10900,"n_placed":128048,"cells":{"deep":18961,"anthem":47399,"passed":18986,"rest":42702},"shares":{"deep":0.1481,"anthem":0.3702,"passed":0.1483,"rest":0.3335}},"albums":[{"slug":"black-sabbath--black-sabbath","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Black Sabbath","year":1970,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Black+Sabbath","min_listeners":85470,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Black Sabbath","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1970-02-13","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":828193,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Black Sabbath","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.779,"least_reached":"Black Sabbath","grid":"few_tracks","median_reach":null,"median_ppl":null,"cells":null,"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Black Sabbath","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Black Sabbath","seconds":380,"listeners":794990,"playcount":4220919,"ppl":5.309,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.648,"ratio":1.142,"dcae":1.104,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.9599,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Black+Sabbath","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.88,"reach_pct":0.9839,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601266"},{"position":2,"name":"The Wizard","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Black Sabbath","seconds":264,"listeners":849364,"playcount":4006687,"ppl":4.717,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.867,"ratio":0.969,"dcae":-0.258,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.0256,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Wizard","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9867,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601287"},{"position":3,"name":"Wasp / Behind the Wall of Sleep / Bassically / N.I.B.","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Black Sabbath","seconds":585,"listeners":109741,"playcount":466481,"ppl":4.251,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"possible undercount: Last.fm lists 'Wasp \\\\ Behind The Wall Of Sleep \\\\ Bassically \\\\ N.I.B.' (2% of the counted listeners) but won't return its counts","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.854,"ratio":1.103,"dcae":0.813,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1325,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Wasp+%2F+Behind+the+Wall+of+Sleep+%2F+Bassically+%2F+N.I.B.+-+2014+Remaster","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.2714,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBAJE7000078"},{"position":4,"name":"Wicked World","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Black Sabbath","seconds":287,"listeners":427353,"playcount":1742998,"ppl":4.079,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.516,"ratio":0.903,"dcae":-0.845,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.516,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Wicked+World","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8869,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBAJE7000083"},{"position":5,"name":"A Bit of Finger / Sleeping Village / Warning","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Black Sabbath","seconds":855,"listeners":88009,"playcount":360260,"ppl":4.093,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"possible undercount: Last.fm lists 'A Bit Of Finger \\\\ Sleeping Village \\\\ Warning' (2% of the counted listeners) but won't return its counts","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.805,"ratio":1.076,"dcae":0.605,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.1063,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/A+Bit+of+Finger+%2F+Sleeping+Village+%2F+Warning+-+2013+Remaster","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.207,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBAJE7000081"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"826c9743-a3f0-3479-bf06-8df2e140ef1d","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--paranoid","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Paranoid","year":1970,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Paranoid","min_listeners":222696,"gate_dcae":1.988,"leader":"Planet Caravan","evidence":"none","null_share":0.9449,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"War Pigs","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1970-09-18","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":2236713,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Paranoid","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.536,"least_reached":"Rat Salad","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.4978,"median_ppl":5.165,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":4,"passed":0,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"War Pigs","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":476,"listeners":1512923,"playcount":8802326,"ppl":5.818,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.415,"ratio":1.074,"dcae":0.568,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6764,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/War+Pigs","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.126,"reach_vs_album":1.359,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7685,"reach_pct":0.9467,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142435"},{"position":2,"name":"Paranoid","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":168,"listeners":3692270,"playcount":27749418,"ppl":7.516,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.965,"ratio":1.26,"dcae":1.828,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.6508,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Paranoid","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.455,"reach_vs_album":3.316,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9946,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142433"},{"position":3,"name":"Planet Caravan","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":268,"listeners":1301807,"playcount":7250287,"ppl":5.569,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.15,"ratio":1.081,"dcae":0.619,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.582,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Planet+Caravan","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.078,"reach_vs_album":1.169,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7835,"reach_pct":0.9173,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142432"},{"position":4,"name":"Iron Man","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":355,"listeners":2339202,"playcount":13636408,"ppl":5.83,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.885,"ratio":0.99,"dcae":-0.076,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.0458,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Iron+Man","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.129,"reach_vs_album":2.101,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9874,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142436"},{"position":5,"name":"Electric Funeral","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":290,"listeners":925162,"playcount":4404989,"ppl":4.761,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.968,"ratio":0.958,"dcae":-0.337,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4136,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Electric+Funeral","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.922,"reach_vs_album":0.831,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.358,"reach_pct":0.8095,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142434"},{"position":6,"name":"Hand of Doom","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":428,"listeners":633155,"playcount":2784373,"ppl":4.398,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.864,"ratio":0.904,"dcae":-0.798,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2831,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Hand+of+Doom","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.852,"reach_vs_album":0.569,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1851,"reach_pct":0.6176,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142438"},{"position":7,"name":"Rat Salad","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":150,"listeners":545271,"playcount":2060280,"ppl":3.778,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.529,"ratio":0.834,"dcae":-1.434,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2438,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Rat+Salad","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.731,"reach_vs_album":0.49,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.0696,"reach_pct":0.5354,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142431"},{"position":8,"name":"Fairies Wear Boots","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Paranoid","seconds":374,"listeners":558943,"playcount":2530446,"ppl":4.527,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.744,"ratio":0.954,"dcae":-0.371,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2499,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Fairies+Wear+Boots","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.876,"reach_vs_album":0.502,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3432,"reach_pct":0.5486,"featuring":[],"isrc":"AUXN22142437"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"cc053745-c447-3566-8f27-bed5438c9133","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--master-of-reality","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Master of Reality","year":1971,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Master+of+Reality","min_listeners":135820,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Into the Void","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1971-07-21","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":907699,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Master of Reality","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.738,"least_reached":"After Forever","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.783,"median_ppl":4.925,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":3,"passed":1,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"Solitude","position":7,"ppl":4.925,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Sweet Leaf","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":306,"listeners":987556,"playcount":5144430,"ppl":5.209,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.202,"ratio":1.001,"dcae":0.023,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.088,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sweet+Leaf","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.058,"reach_vs_album":1.39,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9884,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601271"},{"position":2,"name":"After Forever","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":327,"listeners":466900,"playcount":2044600,"ppl":4.379,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.533,"ratio":0.966,"dcae":-0.575,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5144,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/After+Forever","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.889,"reach_vs_album":0.657,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3887,"reach_pct":0.8858,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602010"},{"position":3,"name":"Children of the Grave","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":300,"listeners":1187040,"playcount":6318605,"ppl":5.323,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.265,"ratio":1.011,"dcae":0.183,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.3077,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Children+of+the+Grave","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.081,"reach_vs_album":1.67,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9919,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":4,"name":"Embryo","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":45,"listeners":40316,"playcount":158838,"ppl":3.94,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"45s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.183,"ratio":1.238,"dcae":3.551,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.0444,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Embryo","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.0621,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":5,"name":"Orchid","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":91,"listeners":772946,"playcount":3103683,"ppl":4.015,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.431,"ratio":0.906,"dcae":-1.638,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.8515,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Orchid","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.815,"reach_vs_album":1.087,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.19,"reach_pct":0.9754,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602011"},{"position":6,"name":"Lord of This World","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":327,"listeners":482625,"playcount":2123705,"ppl":4.4,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.498,"ratio":0.978,"dcae":-0.365,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5317,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Lord+of+This+World","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.893,"reach_vs_album":0.679,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4378,"reach_pct":0.8952,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601282"},{"position":7,"name":"Solitude","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":302,"listeners":647433,"playcount":3188641,"ppl":4.925,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.602,"ratio":1.07,"dcae":1.13,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7133,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Solitude","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":0.911,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.7586,"reach_pct":0.9552,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602013"},{"position":8,"name":"Into the Void","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Master of Reality","seconds":373,"listeners":710773,"playcount":3585990,"ppl":5.045,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.682,"ratio":1.078,"dcae":1.242,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.783,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Into+the+Void","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.024,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7772,"reach_pct":0.9669,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602014"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"e51e9779-2edc-3b39-959c-299fdb5ed940","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--vol-4","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Vol 4","year":1972,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Vol+4","min_listeners":53186,"gate_dcae":2.157,"leader":"Snowblind","evidence":"none","null_share":0.5146,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Snowblind","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1972-09-25","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":33558,"album_listeners_ok":false,"album_listeners_spelling":"Vol 4","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Changes","position":3,"listeners":732634,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Snowblind","position":6,"listeners":567440,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Supernaut","position":5,"listeners":462783,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.998,"least_reached":null,"grid":"album_count","median_reach":null,"median_ppl":null,"cells":null,"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Wheels of Confusion","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":482,"listeners":149898,"playcount":625758,"ppl":4.175,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.056,"ratio":1.029,"dcae":0.304,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Wheels+of+Confusion","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6398,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602039"},{"position":2,"name":"Tomorrow’s Dream","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":193,"listeners":392550,"playcount":1533132,"ppl":3.906,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.532,"ratio":0.862,"dcae":-1.568,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Tomorrow%27s+Dream","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601286"},{"position":3,"name":"Changes","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":286,"listeners":732634,"playcount":3483728,"ppl":4.755,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.614,"ratio":1.031,"dcae":0.317,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Changes","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6465,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601269"},{"position":4,"name":"FX","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":103,"listeners":220698,"playcount":760989,"ppl":3.448,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.872,"ratio":0.89,"dcae":-1.224,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/FX","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1526,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602040"},{"position":5,"name":"Supernaut","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":280,"listeners":462783,"playcount":2185920,"ppl":4.723,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.382,"ratio":1.078,"dcae":0.792,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Supernaut","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7772,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602041"},{"position":6,"name":"Snowblind","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":334,"listeners":567440,"playcount":2945120,"ppl":5.19,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.503,"ratio":1.153,"dcae":1.497,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Snowblind","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8914,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601285"},{"position":7,"name":"Cornucopia","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":235,"listeners":276531,"playcount":1108370,"ppl":4.008,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.105,"ratio":0.976,"dcae":-0.252,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Cornucopia","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4297,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602042"},{"position":8,"name":"Laguna Sunrise","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":176,"listeners":255334,"playcount":960737,"ppl":3.763,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.004,"ratio":0.94,"dcae":-0.655,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Laguna+Sunrise","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2917,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602043"},{"position":9,"name":"St. Vitus Dance","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":150,"listeners":220171,"playcount":829663,"ppl":3.768,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.904,"ratio":0.965,"dcae":-0.373,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/St.+Vitus+Dance","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3848,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602044"},{"position":10,"name":"Under the Sun","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Vol 4","seconds":351,"listeners":132088,"playcount":569867,"ppl":4.314,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.864,"ratio":1.117,"dcae":1.162,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Under+the+Sun","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8477,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602045"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"8c292627-3459-3852-8ebc-226c12db175d","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--sabbath-bloody-sabbath","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","year":1973,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Sabbath+Bloody+Sabbath","min_listeners":60573,"gate_dcae":2.008,"leader":"A National Acrobat","evidence":"none","null_share":0.2193,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"A National Acrobat","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1973-11","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":559287,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.778,"least_reached":"Looking for Today","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.54155,"median_ppl":4.6115,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":4,"passed":0,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":345,"listeners":830733,"playcount":4512298,"ppl":5.432,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.422,"ratio":1.002,"dcae":0.026,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.4853,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sabbath+Bloody+Sabbath","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.178,"reach_vs_album":2.743,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9936,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601273"},{"position":2,"name":"A National Acrobat","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":373,"listeners":332756,"playcount":1745609,"ppl":5.246,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.649,"ratio":1.128,"dcae":1.689,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.595,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/A+National+Acrobat","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.138,"reach_vs_album":1.099,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8631,"reach_pct":0.9226,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602024"},{"position":3,"name":"Fluff","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":249,"listeners":272974,"playcount":1221897,"ppl":4.476,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.451,"ratio":1.006,"dcae":0.078,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4881,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Fluff","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.971,"reach_vs_album":0.901,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5536,"reach_pct":0.8706,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602025"},{"position":4,"name":"Sabbra Cadabra","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":358,"listeners":410971,"playcount":2037974,"ppl":4.959,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.713,"ratio":1.052,"dcae":0.712,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7348,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sabbra+Cadabra","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.075,"reach_vs_album":1.357,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7124,"reach_pct":0.9593,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602026"},{"position":5,"name":"Killing Yourself to Live","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":342,"listeners":351998,"playcount":1671102,"ppl":4.747,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.616,"ratio":1.029,"dcae":0.393,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6294,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Killing+Yourself+to+Live","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.029,"reach_vs_album":1.162,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6398,"reach_pct":0.9339,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601291"},{"position":6,"name":"Who Are You?","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":250,"listeners":227914,"playcount":887112,"ppl":3.892,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.336,"ratio":0.898,"dcae":-1.508,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4075,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Who+Are+You%3F","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.844,"reach_vs_album":0.752,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1703,"reach_pct":0.8034,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602027"},{"position":7,"name":"Looking for Today","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":302,"listeners":227708,"playcount":922797,"ppl":4.053,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.365,"ratio":0.928,"dcae":-1.039,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4071,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Looking+for+Today","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.879,"reach_vs_album":0.752,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2516,"reach_pct":0.8029,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602028"},{"position":8,"name":"Spiral Architect","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabbath Bloody Sabbath","seconds":331,"listeners":264465,"playcount":1145053,"ppl":4.33,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.44,"ratio":0.975,"dcae":-0.352,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4729,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Spiral+Architect","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.939,"reach_vs_album":0.873,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4254,"reach_pct":0.8604,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601276"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"dd9bd473-0232-3a12-b51e-742de1aca5ca","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--sabotage","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Sabotage","year":1975,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Sabotage","min_listeners":35045,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Symptom of the Universe","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1975-07-28","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":241087,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Sabotage","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Symptom of the Universe","position":3,"listeners":367985,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Megalomania","position":4,"listeners":190075,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":1.048,"least_reached":"The Thrill of It All","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.6652,"median_ppl":3.817,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":3,"passed":1,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"The Writ","position":8,"ppl":3.817,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Hole in the Sky","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":240,"listeners":354716,"playcount":1586612,"ppl":4.473,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.189,"ratio":1.068,"dcae":0.859,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.4713,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Hole+in+the+Sky","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.172,"reach_vs_album":2.212,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7534,"reach_pct":0.9936,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601274"},{"position":2,"name":"Don't Start (Too Late)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":49,"listeners":211953,"playcount":815561,"ppl":3.848,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"49s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.657,"ratio":1.052,"dcae":0.665,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.8792,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Don%27t+Start+(Too+Late)","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9783,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602029"},{"position":3,"name":"Symptom of the Universe","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":388,"listeners":367985,"playcount":1715521,"ppl":4.662,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.285,"ratio":1.088,"dcae":1.104,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":1.5264,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Symptom+of+the+Universe","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.221,"reach_vs_album":2.295,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7975,"reach_pct":0.9939,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601275"},{"position":4,"name":"Megalomania","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":583,"listeners":190075,"playcount":829747,"ppl":4.365,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.082,"ratio":1.069,"dcae":0.88,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7884,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Megalomania","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.144,"reach_vs_album":1.185,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7561,"reach_pct":0.9677,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602030"},{"position":5,"name":"The Thrill of It All","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":355,"listeners":104288,"playcount":386632,"ppl":3.707,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.736,"ratio":0.992,"dcae":-0.099,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4326,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Thrill+of+It+All","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.971,"reach_vs_album":0.65,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4959,"reach_pct":0.8276,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602031"},{"position":6,"name":"Supertzar","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":224,"listeners":153773,"playcount":537977,"ppl":3.499,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.784,"ratio":0.925,"dcae":-1.027,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6378,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Supertzar","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.917,"reach_vs_album":0.959,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2422,"reach_pct":0.9363,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602032"},{"position":7,"name":"Am I Going Insane (Radio)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":254,"listeners":160379,"playcount":582402,"ppl":3.631,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.061,"ratio":0.894,"dcae":-1.464,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6652,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Am+I+Going+Insane+(Radio)","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.951,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9436,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601292"},{"position":8,"name":"The Writ","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Sabotage","seconds":494,"listeners":143716,"playcount":548574,"ppl":3.817,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.891,"ratio":0.981,"dcae":-0.252,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5961,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Writ","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":0.896,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.4509,"reach_pct":0.923,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USWB19901290"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"8ef6fc58-d87a-46cf-ab9d-077291784ada","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--technical-ecstasy","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Technical Ecstasy","year":1976,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Technical+Ecstasy","min_listeners":20494,"gate_dcae":1.988,"leader":"She's Gone","evidence":"none","null_share":0.6431,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Dirty Women","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1976-09-25","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":106998,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Technical Ecstasy","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Dirty Women","position":8,"listeners":156396,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"She's Gone","position":7,"listeners":105859,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"You Won't Change Me","position":2,"listeners":104195,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"Rock 'n' Roll Doctor","position":6,"listeners":100752,"singles_out_reached":2}],"depth":1.04,"least_reached":"All Moving Parts (Stand Still)","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.9577,"median_ppl":3.655,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":3,"passed":1,"rest":3},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Back Street Kids","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":229,"listeners":114263,"playcount":401277,"ppl":3.512,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.612,"ratio":0.972,"dcae":-0.593,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.0679,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Back+Street+Kids","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.961,"reach_vs_album":1.115,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4129,"reach_pct":0.9879,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602034"},{"position":2,"name":"You Won't Change Me","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":404,"listeners":104195,"playcount":401803,"ppl":3.856,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.673,"ratio":1.05,"dcae":1.025,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9738,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/You+Won%27t+Change+Me","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.055,"reach_vs_album":1.017,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7065,"reach_pct":0.9847,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602035"},{"position":3,"name":"It's Alright","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":246,"listeners":94493,"playcount":353736,"ppl":3.744,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.766,"ratio":0.994,"dcae":-0.124,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.8831,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/It%27s+Alright","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.024,"reach_vs_album":0.922,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9788,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601294"},{"position":4,"name":"Gypsy","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":312,"listeners":91894,"playcount":327723,"ppl":3.566,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.79,"ratio":0.941,"dcae":-1.286,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.8588,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Gypsy","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.976,"reach_vs_album":0.897,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9762,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602036"},{"position":5,"name":"All Moving Parts (Stand Still)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":306,"listeners":74710,"playcount":257647,"ppl":3.449,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.473,"ratio":0.993,"dcae":-0.149,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6982,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/All+Moving+Parts+(Stand+Still)","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.944,"reach_vs_album":0.729,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4998,"reach_pct":0.9519,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602037"},{"position":6,"name":"Rock 'n' Roll Doctor","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":215,"listeners":100752,"playcount":334535,"ppl":3.32,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.506,"ratio":0.947,"dcae":-1.147,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9416,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Rock+%27N%27+Roll+Doctor","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.908,"reach_vs_album":0.983,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3168,"reach_pct":0.9829,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601277"},{"position":7,"name":"She's Gone","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":297,"listeners":105859,"playcount":399756,"ppl":3.776,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.572,"ratio":1.057,"dcae":1.175,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9894,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/She%27s+Gone","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.033,"reach_vs_album":1.033,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.726,"reach_pct":0.9854,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602038"},{"position":8,"name":"Dirty Women","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Technical Ecstasy","seconds":429,"listeners":156396,"playcount":621983,"ppl":3.977,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.775,"ratio":1.053,"dcae":1.1,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":1.4617,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Dirty+Women","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.088,"reach_vs_album":1.526,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7152,"reach_pct":0.9935,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601278"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"de117377-2f09-3502-8959-e1eca1b583a8","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--never-say-die","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Never Say Die!","year":1978,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Never+Say+Die!","min_listeners":17647,"gate_dcae":2.065,"leader":"Junior’s Eyes","evidence":"none","null_share":0.5598,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Junior’s Eyes","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1978-09-28","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":159438,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Never Say Die!","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Johnny Blade","position":2,"listeners":94899,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Air Dance","position":6,"listeners":93173,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Shock Wave","position":5,"listeners":89741,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Junior’s Eyes","position":3,"listeners":88238,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.736,"least_reached":"Breakout","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.5534,"median_ppl":3.554,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":4,"passed":1,"rest":3},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Never Say Die","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":227,"listeners":290457,"playcount":1267880,"ppl":4.365,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.192,"ratio":1.041,"dcae":0.803,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":1.8218,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Never+Say+Die","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.228,"reach_vs_album":3.292,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9955,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601264"},{"position":2,"name":"Johnny Blade","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":387,"listeners":94899,"playcount":356128,"ppl":3.753,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.605,"ratio":1.041,"dcae":0.794,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5952,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Johnny+Blade","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.056,"reach_vs_album":1.076,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6792,"reach_pct":0.9227,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602020"},{"position":3,"name":"Junior’s Eyes","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":401,"listeners":88238,"playcount":337616,"ppl":3.826,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.577,"ratio":1.07,"dcae":1.337,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.5534,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Junior%27s+Eyes","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.077,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7586,"reach_pct":0.9053,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602021"},{"position":4,"name":"A Hard Road","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":363,"listeners":86838,"playcount":308580,"ppl":3.554,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.774,"ratio":0.942,"dcae":-1.193,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5447,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/A+Hard+Road","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":0.984,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9012,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1601281"},{"position":5,"name":"Shock Wave","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":313,"listeners":89741,"playcount":301681,"ppl":3.362,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.521,"ratio":0.955,"dcae":-0.917,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5629,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Shock+Wave","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.946,"reach_vs_album":1.017,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3467,"reach_pct":0.9094,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602019"},{"position":6,"name":"Air Dance","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":315,"listeners":93173,"playcount":345024,"ppl":3.703,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.527,"ratio":1.05,"dcae":0.969,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5844,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Air+Dance","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.042,"reach_vs_album":1.056,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7065,"reach_pct":0.9184,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602016"},{"position":7,"name":"Over to You","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":321,"listeners":83303,"playcount":275876,"ppl":3.312,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.482,"ratio":0.951,"dcae":-0.994,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5225,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Over+to+You","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.932,"reach_vs_album":0.944,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3317,"reach_pct":0.8906,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602015"},{"position":8,"name":"Breakout","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":156,"listeners":71639,"playcount":236963,"ppl":3.308,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.297,"ratio":1.003,"dcae":0.063,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4493,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Breakout","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.931,"reach_vs_album":0.812,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5413,"reach_pct":0.8422,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602017"},{"position":9,"name":"Swinging the Chain","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Never Say Die!","seconds":258,"listeners":78337,"playcount":255410,"ppl":3.26,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.405,"ratio":0.957,"dcae":-0.863,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4913,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Swinging+the+Chain","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.917,"reach_vs_album":0.888,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3541,"reach_pct":0.8727,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GB5KW1602018"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"eb8c8e6c-b554-31d3-bae0-1c4ea64336d0","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--heaven-and-hell","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Heaven and Hell","year":1980,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Heaven+and+Hell","min_listeners":53662,"gate_dcae":1.952,"leader":"Heaven and Hell","evidence":"none","null_share":0.5636,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Heaven and Hell","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1980-04-25","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":355103,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Heaven and Hell","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Heaven and Hell","position":4,"listeners":823577,"singles_out_reached":3},{"name":"Children of the Sea","position":2,"listeners":331174,"singles_out_reached":2}],"depth":1.06,"least_reached":"Walk Away","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.7556,"median_ppl":4.952,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":4,"passed":0,"rest":4},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Neon Knights","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":233,"listeners":345560,"playcount":1922773,"ppl":5.564,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.165,"ratio":1.077,"dcae":0.817,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9731,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Neon+Knights","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.124,"reach_vs_album":1.288,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9846,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900395"},{"position":2,"name":"Children of the Sea","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":335,"listeners":331174,"playcount":1764084,"ppl":5.327,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.907,"ratio":1.086,"dcae":0.901,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9326,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Children+of+the+Sea","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.076,"reach_vs_album":1.234,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7938,"reach_pct":0.9823,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900390"},{"position":3,"name":"Lady Evil","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":263,"listeners":251831,"playcount":1152648,"ppl":4.577,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.006,"ratio":0.914,"dcae":-0.983,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7092,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Lady+Evil","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.924,"reach_vs_album":0.939,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9544,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900393"},{"position":4,"name":"Heaven and Hell","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":416,"listeners":823577,"playcount":4948097,"ppl":6.008,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":5.409,"ratio":1.111,"dcae":1.153,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":2.3193,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Heaven+and+Hell","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.213,"reach_vs_album":3.069,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8381,"reach_pct":0.9968,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900392"},{"position":5,"name":"Wishing Well","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":248,"listeners":202205,"playcount":870844,"ppl":4.307,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.56,"ratio":0.945,"dcae":-0.626,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5694,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Wishing+Well","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.87,"reach_vs_album":0.754,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3096,"reach_pct":0.9122,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900397"},{"position":6,"name":"Die Young","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":285,"listeners":284798,"playcount":1532111,"ppl":5.38,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.047,"ratio":1.066,"dcae":0.7,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.802,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Die+Young","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.086,"reach_vs_album":1.061,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9695,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900391"},{"position":7,"name":"Walk Away","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":265,"listeners":168162,"playcount":658732,"ppl":3.917,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.466,"ratio":0.877,"dcae":-1.438,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4736,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Walk+Away","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.791,"reach_vs_album":0.627,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1277,"reach_pct":0.8609,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900396"},{"position":8,"name":"Lonely Is the Word","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Heaven and Hell","seconds":346,"listeners":185183,"playcount":804898,"ppl":4.347,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.559,"ratio":0.953,"dcae":-0.523,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5215,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Lonely+Is+the+Word","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.878,"reach_vs_album":0.69,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3394,"reach_pct":0.8902,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900394"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"43ac82b5-eceb-3909-a153-3c00ea9c7b9a","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--mob-rules","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Mob Rules","year":1981,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Mob+Rules","min_listeners":24896,"gate_dcae":2.091,"leader":"The Mob Rules","evidence":"none","null_share":0.6819,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"The Mob Rules","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1981-11-04","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":229810,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Mob Rules","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"The Mob Rules","position":5,"listeners":204117,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.966,"least_reached":"Over and Over","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.5417,"median_ppl":4.358,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":4,"passed":1,"rest":3},"deep_cut":{"name":"Falling Off the Edge of the World","position":8,"ppl":4.374,"ppl_vs_album":1.004,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Turn Up the Night","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":219,"listeners":172222,"playcount":718085,"ppl":4.17,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.597,"ratio":0.907,"dcae":-1.273,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7494,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Turn+Up+the+Night","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.957,"reach_vs_album":1.383,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9617,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900381"},{"position":2,"name":"Voodoo","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":271,"listeners":156005,"playcount":679881,"ppl":4.358,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.311,"ratio":1.011,"dcae":0.141,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6788,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Voodoo","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":1.253,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5725,"reach_pct":0.9473,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900382"},{"position":3,"name":"The Sign of the Southern Cross","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":465,"listeners":131034,"playcount":592902,"ppl":4.525,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.344,"ratio":1.042,"dcae":0.533,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5702,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Sign+of+the+Southern+Cross","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.038,"reach_vs_album":1.053,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6824,"reach_pct":0.9125,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900383"},{"position":4,"name":"E5150","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":175,"listeners":102730,"playcount":384648,"ppl":3.744,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.022,"ratio":0.931,"dcae":-0.934,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.447,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/E5150","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.859,"reach_vs_album":0.825,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2615,"reach_pct":0.8406,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900384"},{"position":5,"name":"The Mob Rules","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":193,"listeners":204117,"playcount":974002,"ppl":4.772,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.322,"ratio":1.104,"dcae":1.292,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.8882,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Mob+Rules","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.095,"reach_vs_album":1.64,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8268,"reach_pct":0.9792,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":6,"name":"Country Girl","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":241,"listeners":124481,"playcount":559415,"ppl":4.494,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.148,"ratio":1.083,"dcae":1.044,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5417,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Country+Girl","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.031,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7875,"reach_pct":0.9,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900385"},{"position":7,"name":"Slipping Away","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":222,"listeners":95601,"playcount":347278,"ppl":3.633,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.013,"ratio":0.905,"dcae":-1.297,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.416,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Slipping+Away","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.834,"reach_vs_album":0.768,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1876,"reach_pct":0.8122,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":8,"name":"Falling Off the Edge of the World","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":302,"listeners":106060,"playcount":463866,"ppl":4.374,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.109,"ratio":1.064,"dcae":0.814,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4615,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Falling+Off+the+Edge+of+the+World","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.004,"reach_vs_album":0.852,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.7436,"reach_pct":0.8521,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900388"},{"position":9,"name":"Over and Over","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Mob Rules","seconds":327,"listeners":91519,"playcount":362140,"ppl":3.957,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.055,"ratio":0.976,"dcae":-0.319,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3982,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Over+and+Over","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.908,"reach_vs_album":0.735,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4297,"reach_pct":0.7931,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900387"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"35cb9c0a-3cce-3efd-ac19-014f4811620d","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--born-again","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Born Again","year":1983,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Born+Again","min_listeners":14102,"gate_dcae":2.008,"leader":"Born Again","evidence":"leading","null_share":0.1012,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Born Again","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1983-08-07","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":116765,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Born Again","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.978,"least_reached":"Keep It Warm","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.6064,"median_ppl":3.6605,"cells":{"deep":2,"anthem":2,"passed":2,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"Born Again","position":7,"ppl":4.378,"ppl_vs_album":1.196,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Trashed","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":257,"listeners":83459,"playcount":305069,"ppl":3.655,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.94,"ratio":0.928,"dcae":-0.793,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7148,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Trashed","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.998,"reach_vs_album":1.179,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9555,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900618"},{"position":2,"name":"Stonehenge","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":118,"listeners":71755,"playcount":225772,"ppl":3.146,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.494,"ratio":0.9,"dcae":-1.107,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6145,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Stonehenge","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.859,"reach_vs_album":1.013,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1753,"reach_pct":0.9293,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900619"},{"position":3,"name":"Disturbing the Priest","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":349,"listeners":71097,"playcount":260630,"ppl":3.666,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.681,"ratio":0.996,"dcae":-0.042,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6089,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Disturbing+the+Priest","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.002,"reach_vs_album":1.004,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5119,"reach_pct":0.9276,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900620"},{"position":4,"name":"The Dark","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":45,"listeners":62815,"playcount":310484,"ppl":4.943,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"45s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.266,"ratio":1.513,"dcae":4.376,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.538,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Dark","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8983,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900621"},{"position":5,"name":"Zero the Hero","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":455,"listeners":75819,"playcount":306209,"ppl":4.039,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.737,"ratio":1.081,"dcae":0.821,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6493,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Zero+the+Hero","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.103,"reach_vs_album":1.071,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7835,"reach_pct":0.9395,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900622"},{"position":6,"name":"Digital Bitch","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":219,"listeners":64961,"playcount":238539,"ppl":3.672,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.536,"ratio":1.039,"dcae":0.4,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5563,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Digital+Bitch","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.003,"reach_vs_album":0.917,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6731,"reach_pct":0.9066,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900623"},{"position":7,"name":"Born Again","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":394,"listeners":70512,"playcount":308692,"ppl":4.378,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.664,"ratio":1.195,"dcae":1.879,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6039,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Born+Again","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.196,"reach_vs_album":0.996,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.9258,"reach_pct":0.9259,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900624"},{"position":8,"name":"Hot Line","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":293,"listeners":58049,"playcount":198379,"ppl":3.417,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.531,"ratio":0.968,"dcae":-0.345,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4971,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Hot+Line","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.933,"reach_vs_album":0.82,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3971,"reach_pct":0.8764,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900625"},{"position":9,"name":"Keep It Warm","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Born Again","seconds":336,"listeners":53571,"playcount":174512,"ppl":3.258,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.518,"ratio":0.926,"dcae":-0.813,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4588,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Keep+It+Warm","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.89,"reach_vs_album":0.757,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2452,"reach_pct":0.85,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900626"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"de7de788-0f31-338a-9d82-8a09108e429f","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath-featuring-tony-iommi--seventh-star","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","title":"Seventh Star","year":1986,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/+noredirect/Black+Sabbath+Featuring+Tony+Iommi/Seventh+Star","min_listeners":8508,"gate_dcae":2.008,"leader":"Danger Zone","evidence":"none","null_share":0.6216,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Danger Zone","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1986-01-28","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":539,"album_listeners_ok":false,"album_listeners_spelling":"Seventh Star","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.892,"least_reached":null,"grid":"album_count","median_reach":null,"median_ppl":null,"cells":null,"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"In for the Kill","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":220,"listeners":49344,"playcount":152516,"ppl":3.091,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.428,"ratio":0.902,"dcae":-1.383,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/In+For+The+Kill","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.18,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900403"},{"position":2,"name":"No Stranger to Love","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":268,"listeners":73691,"playcount":298033,"ppl":4.044,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.83,"ratio":1.056,"dcae":0.728,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/No+Stranger+to+Love","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900404"},{"position":3,"name":"Turn to Stone","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":208,"listeners":40539,"playcount":126681,"ppl":3.125,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.335,"ratio":0.937,"dcae":-0.869,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Turn+to+Stone","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2816,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900405"},{"position":4,"name":"Sphinx (The Guardian)","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":71,"listeners":40388,"playcount":118429,"ppl":2.932,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"71s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.148,"ratio":0.931,"dcae":-0.948,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sphinx+(The+Guardian)","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900406"},{"position":5,"name":"Seventh Star","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":320,"listeners":45197,"playcount":161944,"ppl":3.583,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.43,"ratio":1.045,"dcae":0.584,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Seventh+Star","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6912,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900407"},{"position":6,"name":"Danger Zone","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":263,"listeners":44403,"playcount":165305,"ppl":3.723,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.381,"ratio":1.101,"dcae":1.285,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Danger+Zone","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8218,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900408"},{"position":7,"name":"Heart Like a Wheel","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":395,"listeners":42542,"playcount":133985,"ppl":3.149,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.429,"ratio":0.918,"dcae":-1.136,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Heart+Like+A+Wheel","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2211,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900409"},{"position":8,"name":"Angry Heart","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":186,"listeners":41593,"playcount":137372,"ppl":3.303,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.284,"ratio":1.006,"dcae":0.075,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Angry+Heart","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5536,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900410"},{"position":9,"name":"In Memory…","artist":"Black Sabbath featuring Tony Iommi","album":"Seventh Star","seconds":155,"listeners":42035,"playcount":144101,"ppl":3.428,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.249,"ratio":1.055,"dcae":0.715,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":null,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/In+Memory","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7207,"reach_pct":null,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900411"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"9ff01b54-79d5-343b-9a52-242e5627d652","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--the-eternal-idol","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"The Eternal Idol","year":1987,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/The+Eternal+Idol","min_listeners":9836,"gate_dcae":2.091,"leader":"Born to Lose","evidence":"none","null_share":0.8957,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Born to Lose","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1987-11-01","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":78217,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"The Eternal Idol","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.923,"least_reached":"Hard Life to Love","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.6288,"median_ppl":3.253,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":4,"passed":1,"rest":3},"deep_cut":{"name":"Eternal Idol","position":9,"ppl":3.321,"ppl_vs_album":1.021,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"The Shining","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":359,"listeners":67853,"playcount":263893,"ppl":3.889,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.685,"ratio":1.055,"dcae":1.339,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.8675,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Shining","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.196,"reach_vs_album":1.38,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9771,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900412"},{"position":2,"name":"Ancient Warrior","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":332,"listeners":52824,"playcount":172504,"ppl":3.266,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.353,"ratio":0.974,"dcae":-0.653,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6754,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Ancient+Warrior","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.004,"reach_vs_album":1.074,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4211,"reach_pct":0.9464,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900413"},{"position":3,"name":"Hard Life to Love","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":300,"listeners":35848,"playcount":109706,"ppl":3.06,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.2,"ratio":0.956,"dcae":-1.105,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4583,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Hard+Life+To+Love","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.941,"reach_vs_album":0.729,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3505,"reach_pct":0.8494,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900414"},{"position":4,"name":"Glory Ride","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":289,"listeners":49184,"playcount":160014,"ppl":3.253,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.289,"ratio":0.989,"dcae":-0.271,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6288,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Glory+Ride","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4836,"reach_pct":0.9337,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900415"},{"position":5,"name":"Born to Lose","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":224,"listeners":51567,"playcount":174928,"ppl":3.392,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.254,"ratio":1.042,"dcae":1.03,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6593,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Born+To+Lose","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.043,"reach_vs_album":1.049,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6824,"reach_pct":0.9422,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900416"},{"position":6,"name":"Nightmare","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":320,"listeners":46541,"playcount":142368,"ppl":3.059,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.272,"ratio":0.935,"dcae":-1.669,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.595,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Nightmare","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.94,"reach_vs_album":0.946,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.275,"reach_pct":0.9226,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900417"},{"position":7,"name":"Scarlet Pimpernel","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":128,"listeners":50159,"playcount":159983,"ppl":3.19,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.138,"ratio":1.016,"dcae":0.4,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6413,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Scarlet+Pimpernel","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.981,"reach_vs_album":1.02,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5922,"reach_pct":0.9373,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900418"},{"position":8,"name":"Lost Forever","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":244,"listeners":46351,"playcount":150662,"ppl":3.25,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.21,"ratio":1.013,"dcae":0.311,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5926,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Lost+Forever","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.999,"reach_vs_album":0.942,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5805,"reach_pct":0.9215,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900419"},{"position":9,"name":"Eternal Idol","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"The Eternal Idol","seconds":395,"listeners":40684,"playcount":135110,"ppl":3.321,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.239,"ratio":1.025,"dcae":0.619,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5201,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Eternal+Idol","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.021,"reach_vs_album":0.827,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.6256,"reach_pct":0.8894,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM70900420"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"fb123ba6-4a78-3ed3-bee3-cf939fac6411","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--headless-cross","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Headless Cross","year":1989,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Headless+Cross","min_listeners":10367,"gate_dcae":null,"leader":null,"evidence":"none","null_share":null,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"When Death Calls","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1989-06-07","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":85090,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Headless Cross","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"When Death Calls","position":4,"listeners":53996,"singles_out_reached":2},{"name":"Kill in the Spirit World","position":5,"listeners":45187,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Nightwing","position":8,"listeners":43065,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.879,"least_reached":"Nightwing","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.6282,"median_ppl":3.886,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":3,"passed":1,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"Nightwing","position":8,"ppl":3.886,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"The Gates of Hell","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":67,"listeners":50223,"playcount":173636,"ppl":3.457,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"67s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.58,"ratio":0.966,"dcae":-0.424,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5902,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Gates+of+Hell","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9206,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900005"},{"position":2,"name":"Headless Cross","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":389,"listeners":79831,"playcount":388727,"ppl":4.869,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.357,"ratio":1.118,"dcae":1.355,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9382,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Headless+Cross","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.253,"reach_vs_album":1.493,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9827,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900006"},{"position":3,"name":"Devil & Daughter","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":285,"listeners":56596,"playcount":221288,"ppl":3.91,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.131,"ratio":0.947,"dcae":-0.669,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6651,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Devil+and+Daughter","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.006,"reach_vs_album":1.059,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9436,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900007"},{"position":4,"name":"When Death Calls","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":416,"listeners":53996,"playcount":233240,"ppl":4.32,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.925,"ratio":1.1,"dcae":1.166,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6346,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/When+Death+Calls","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.112,"reach_vs_album":1.01,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8202,"reach_pct":0.9354,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900008"},{"position":5,"name":"Kill in the Spirit World","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":311,"listeners":45187,"playcount":169933,"ppl":3.761,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.788,"ratio":0.993,"dcae":-0.088,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.531,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Kill+in+the+Spirit+World","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.968,"reach_vs_album":0.845,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4998,"reach_pct":0.895,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900009"},{"position":6,"name":"Call of the Wild","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":319,"listeners":38383,"playcount":137582,"ppl":3.584,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.962,"ratio":0.905,"dcae":-1.219,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4511,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Call+of+the+Wild","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.922,"reach_vs_album":0.718,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8436,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900010"},{"position":7,"name":"Black Moon","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":246,"listeners":53450,"playcount":200600,"ppl":3.753,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.031,"ratio":0.931,"dcae":-0.87,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6282,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Black+Moon","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.966,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9335,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900011"},{"position":8,"name":"Nightwing","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Headless Cross","seconds":395,"listeners":43065,"playcount":167371,"ppl":3.886,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.784,"ratio":1.027,"dcae":0.325,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5061,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Nightwing","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":0.806,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.6327,"reach_pct":0.8814,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR38900012"}],"concentration":null,"tier_pct":null,"set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"230fa643-0fdf-34a4-b6e4-3cf8563dcf11","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--tyr","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"TYR","year":1990,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Tyr","min_listeners":7598,"gate_dcae":1.988,"leader":"Valhalla","evidence":"none","null_share":0.6781,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Valhalla","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1990-08-20","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":51891,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"TYR","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Valhalla","position":7,"listeners":39511,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"The Sabbath Stones","position":4,"listeners":38693,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Odin’s Court","position":6,"listeners":38112,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"The Law Maker","position":2,"listeners":37861,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Heaven in Black","position":9,"listeners":35882,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.956,"least_reached":"Jerusalem","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.73205,"median_ppl":3.8455,"cells":{"deep":2,"anthem":2,"passed":2,"rest":2},"deep_cut":{"name":"Jerusalem","position":3,"ppl":3.955,"ppl_vs_album":1.028,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Anno Mundi (The Vision)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":373,"listeners":46752,"playcount":205723,"ppl":4.4,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.268,"ratio":1.031,"dcae":0.711,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.901,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Anno+Mundi","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.144,"reach_vs_album":1.231,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9803,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000013"},{"position":2,"name":"The Law Maker","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":235,"listeners":37861,"playcount":146313,"ppl":3.864,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.823,"ratio":1.011,"dcae":0.249,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7296,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Law+Maker","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.005,"reach_vs_album":0.997,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5725,"reach_pct":0.9584,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000014"},{"position":3,"name":"Jerusalem","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":240,"listeners":33155,"playcount":131140,"ppl":3.955,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.767,"ratio":1.05,"dcae":1.135,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6389,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Jerusalem","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.028,"reach_vs_album":0.873,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.7065,"reach_pct":0.9366,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000015"},{"position":4,"name":"The Sabbath Stones","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":408,"listeners":38693,"playcount":145332,"ppl":3.756,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.922,"ratio":0.958,"dcae":-1.008,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7457,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Sabbath+Stones","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.977,"reach_vs_album":1.019,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.358,"reach_pct":0.9611,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000016"},{"position":5,"name":"The Battle of Tyr","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":69,"listeners":37994,"playcount":137632,"ppl":3.622,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":true,"interlude_reason":"69s long (under 90s)","eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.567,"ratio":1.016,"dcae":0.362,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7322,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Battle+of+Tyr","cell":null,"situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":null,"reach_vs_album":null,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9587,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000017"},{"position":6,"name":"Odin’s Court","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":163,"listeners":38112,"playcount":142367,"ppl":3.735,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.719,"ratio":1.004,"dcae":0.105,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7345,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Odin%27s+Court","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.971,"reach_vs_album":1.003,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5458,"reach_pct":0.9592,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000018"},{"position":7,"name":"Valhalla","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":283,"listeners":39511,"playcount":158862,"ppl":4.021,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.83,"ratio":1.05,"dcae":1.136,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.7614,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Valhalla","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.046,"reach_vs_album":1.04,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7065,"reach_pct":0.9636,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000019"},{"position":8,"name":"Feels Good to Me","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":344,"listeners":35560,"playcount":136080,"ppl":3.827,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.065,"ratio":0.941,"dcae":-1.407,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6853,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Feels+Good+to+Me","cell":"rest","situation":"single_missed","ppl_vs_album":0.995,"reach_vs_album":0.936,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9487,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000020"},{"position":9,"name":"Heaven in Black","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"TYR","seconds":246,"listeners":35882,"playcount":129256,"ppl":3.602,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.747,"ratio":0.961,"dcae":-0.92,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6915,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Heaven+in+Black","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.937,"reach_vs_album":0.945,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3693,"reach_pct":0.9502,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39000021"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"00f64d57-aeaf-3925-ac5e-072fdcb7c3f6","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--dehumanizer","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Dehumanizer","year":1992,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Dehumanizer","min_listeners":14570,"gate_dcae":2.139,"leader":"Time Machine","evidence":"none","null_share":0.6737,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Computer God","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1992-06-22","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":161941,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Dehumanizer","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"After All (The Dead)","position":2,"listeners":94230,"singles_out_reached":1},{"name":"Time Machine","position":6,"listeners":85559,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.872,"least_reached":"Buried Alive","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.4499,"median_ppl":3.91,"cells":{"deep":0,"anthem":6,"passed":0,"rest":5},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"Computer God","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":375,"listeners":98079,"playcount":411944,"ppl":4.2,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.038,"ratio":1.04,"dcae":0.831,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6056,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Computer+God","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.074,"reach_vs_album":1.346,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.676,"reach_pct":0.9265,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003159"},{"position":2,"name":"After All (The Dead)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":342,"listeners":94230,"playcount":368409,"ppl":3.91,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.995,"ratio":0.979,"dcae":-0.456,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5819,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/After+All+(The+Dead)","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.0,"reach_vs_album":1.293,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4421,"reach_pct":0.9172,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003160"},{"position":3,"name":"TV Crimes","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":243,"listeners":102672,"playcount":436680,"ppl":4.253,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.208,"ratio":1.011,"dcae":0.224,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.634,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/TV+Crimes","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.088,"reach_vs_album":1.409,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9353,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003161"},{"position":4,"name":"Letters From Earth","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":257,"listeners":70703,"playcount":264045,"ppl":3.735,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.81,"ratio":0.98,"dcae":-0.422,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4366,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Letters+From+Earth","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.955,"reach_vs_album":0.97,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4466,"reach_pct":0.8311,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003162"},{"position":5,"name":"Master of Insanity","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":355,"listeners":72853,"playcount":294018,"ppl":4.036,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.129,"ratio":0.978,"dcae":-0.48,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4499,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Master+Of+Insanity","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.032,"reach_vs_album":1.0,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8426,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003163"},{"position":6,"name":"Time Machine","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":256,"listeners":85559,"playcount":349985,"ppl":4.091,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.868,"ratio":1.058,"dcae":1.181,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5283,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Time+Machine","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.046,"reach_vs_album":1.174,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7286,"reach_pct":0.8935,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003164"},{"position":7,"name":"Sins of the Father","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":287,"listeners":64504,"playcount":226102,"ppl":3.505,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.774,"ratio":0.929,"dcae":-1.56,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3983,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sins+Of+The+Father","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.896,"reach_vs_album":0.885,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2548,"reach_pct":0.7932,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003165"},{"position":8,"name":"Too Late","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":415,"listeners":63658,"playcount":236783,"ppl":3.72,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.833,"ratio":0.97,"dcae":-0.635,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3931,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Too+Late","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.951,"reach_vs_album":0.874,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4047,"reach_pct":0.7874,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003166"},{"position":9,"name":"I","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":314,"listeners":106786,"playcount":492545,"ppl":4.612,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.231,"ratio":1.09,"dcae":1.823,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6594,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/I","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.18,"reach_vs_album":1.466,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9423,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003167"},{"position":10,"name":"Buried Alive","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":293,"listeners":62354,"playcount":223195,"ppl":3.579,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.743,"ratio":0.956,"dcae":-0.945,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.385,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Buried+Alive","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.915,"reach_vs_album":0.856,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3505,"reach_pct":0.7779,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003168"},{"position":11,"name":"Time Machine (Wayne's World version)","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Dehumanizer","seconds":259,"listeners":11833,"playcount":37937,"ppl":3.206,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.14,"ratio":1.021,"dcae":0.441,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.0731,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Time+Machine+(Wayne%27s+World+version)","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.82,"reach_vs_album":0.162,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.1276,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USCA21003176"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"within the pack","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"0db80cc3-becc-3ee7-8abe-de42d368ca54","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--cross-purposes","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Cross Purposes","year":1994,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Cross+Purposes","min_listeners":7104,"gate_dcae":2.172,"leader":"Cross of Thorns","evidence":"none","null_share":0.3319,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Cross of Thorns","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1994-01-26","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":53217,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Cross Purposes","sleeper_hits":null,"depth":null,"least_reached":"The Hand That Rocks the Cradle","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.66755,"median_ppl":3.491,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":4,"passed":1,"rest":4},"deep_cut":{"name":"The Hand That Rocks the Cradle","position":8,"ppl":3.527,"ppl_vs_album":1.01,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"I Witness","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":299,"listeners":38809,"playcount":149767,"ppl":3.859,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.688,"ratio":1.046,"dcae":0.469,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7293,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/I+Witness","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.105,"reach_vs_album":1.093,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6945,"reach_pct":0.9583,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710423"},{"position":2,"name":"Cross of Thorns","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":274,"listeners":40971,"playcount":177995,"ppl":4.344,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.684,"ratio":1.179,"dcae":1.708,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.7699,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Cross+of+Thorns","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.244,"reach_vs_album":1.153,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.9146,"reach_pct":0.965,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710424"},{"position":3,"name":"Psychophobia","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":195,"listeners":37391,"playcount":140018,"ppl":3.745,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.58,"ratio":1.046,"dcae":0.467,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7026,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Psychophobia","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.073,"reach_vs_album":1.053,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6945,"reach_pct":0.953,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USIR39400038"},{"position":4,"name":"Virtual Death","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":349,"listeners":35239,"playcount":121738,"ppl":3.455,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.658,"ratio":0.944,"dcae":-0.592,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6622,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Virtual+Death","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.99,"reach_vs_album":0.992,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3061,"reach_pct":0.9429,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710425"},{"position":5,"name":"Immaculate Deception","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":255,"listeners":32707,"playcount":107992,"ppl":3.302,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.565,"ratio":0.926,"dcae":-0.794,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6146,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Immaculate+Deception","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.946,"reach_vs_album":0.921,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2452,"reach_pct":0.9294,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710426"},{"position":6,"name":"Dying for Love","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":354,"listeners":37683,"playcount":158332,"ppl":4.202,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.669,"ratio":1.145,"dcae":1.404,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.7081,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Dying+for+Love","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.204,"reach_vs_album":1.061,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.8835,"reach_pct":0.9542,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710427"},{"position":7,"name":"Back to Eden","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":237,"listeners":32925,"playcount":106636,"ppl":3.239,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.539,"ratio":0.915,"dcae":-0.917,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6187,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Back+to+Eden","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.928,"reach_vs_album":0.927,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2135,"reach_pct":0.9307,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710428"},{"position":8,"name":"The Hand That Rocks the Cradle","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":270,"listeners":25992,"playcount":91662,"ppl":3.527,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.471,"ratio":1.016,"dcae":0.165,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4884,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Hand+That+Rocks+the+Cradle","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.01,"reach_vs_album":0.732,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.5922,"reach_pct":0.8708,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710429"},{"position":9,"name":"Cardinal Sin","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":261,"listeners":31021,"playcount":99210,"ppl":3.198,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.52,"ratio":0.909,"dcae":-0.992,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5829,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Cardinal+Sin","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.916,"reach_vs_album":0.873,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.1977,"reach_pct":0.9177,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710430"},{"position":10,"name":"Evil Eye","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Cross Purposes","seconds":357,"listeners":35808,"playcount":118658,"ppl":3.314,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.621,"ratio":0.915,"dcae":-0.917,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6729,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Evil+Eye","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.949,"reach_vs_album":1.008,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2135,"reach_pct":0.9457,"featuring":[],"isrc":"USNPD0710431"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"0a321887-9d3d-3600-90d1-67540a409177","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--forbidden","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"Forbidden","year":1995,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/Forbidden","min_listeners":5306,"gate_dcae":2.157,"leader":"I Won't Cry for You","evidence":"leading","null_share":0.1083,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"I Won't Cry for You","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"1995-06-07","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":48153,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"Forbidden","sleeper_hits":[],"depth":0.987,"least_reached":"Guilty as Hell","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.551,"median_ppl":3.305,"cells":{"deep":2,"anthem":3,"passed":2,"rest":3},"deep_cut":{"name":"Forbidden","position":9,"ppl":3.409,"ppl_vs_album":1.031,"featuring":[]},"no_deep_cut":null,"tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"The Illusion of Power","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":294,"listeners":27601,"playcount":89899,"ppl":3.257,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.39,"ratio":0.961,"dcae":-0.486,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5732,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/The+Illusion+of+Power","cell":"passed","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.985,"reach_vs_album":1.04,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3693,"reach_pct":0.9138,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":2,"name":"Get a Grip","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":240,"listeners":31503,"playcount":100184,"ppl":3.18,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":3.612,"ratio":0.88,"dcae":-1.551,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.6542,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Get+a+Grip","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.962,"reach_vs_album":1.187,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9409,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":3,"name":"Can't Get Close Enough","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":269,"listeners":26648,"playcount":89737,"ppl":3.367,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.348,"ratio":1.006,"dcae":0.071,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5534,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Can%27t+Get+Close+Enough","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.019,"reach_vs_album":1.004,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5536,"reach_pct":0.9053,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":4,"name":"Shaking Off the Chains","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":244,"listeners":25319,"playcount":80149,"ppl":3.166,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.307,"ratio":0.957,"dcae":-0.532,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5258,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Shaking+Off+the+Chains","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.958,"reach_vs_album":0.954,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.3541,"reach_pct":0.8924,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":5,"name":"I Won't Cry for You","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":288,"listeners":28975,"playcount":115132,"ppl":3.973,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.373,"ratio":1.178,"dcae":1.993,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.6017,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/I+Won%27t+Cry+for+You","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.202,"reach_vs_album":1.092,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.9138,"reach_pct":0.9252,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":6,"name":"Guilty as Hell","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":209,"listeners":21384,"playcount":71711,"ppl":3.353,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.212,"ratio":1.044,"dcae":0.526,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4441,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Guilty+as+Hell","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.015,"reach_vs_album":0.806,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.6883,"reach_pct":0.8381,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":7,"name":"Sick and Tired","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":212,"listeners":26417,"playcount":79805,"ppl":3.021,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.276,"ratio":0.922,"dcae":-0.987,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5486,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Sick+and+Tired","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.914,"reach_vs_album":0.996,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.2332,"reach_pct":0.903,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":8,"name":"Rusty Angels","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":301,"listeners":25532,"playcount":82859,"ppl":3.245,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.317,"ratio":0.978,"dcae":-0.265,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5302,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Rusty+Angels","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.982,"reach_vs_album":0.962,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.4378,"reach_pct":0.8946,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":9,"name":"Forbidden","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":229,"listeners":25790,"playcount":87906,"ppl":3.409,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.267,"ratio":1.043,"dcae":0.517,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5356,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Forbidden","cell":"deep","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.031,"reach_vs_album":0.972,"is_deep_cut":true,"ratio_pct":0.6854,"reach_pct":0.8971,"featuring":[],"isrc":null},{"position":10,"name":"Kiss of Death","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"Forbidden","seconds":369,"listeners":28154,"playcount":100614,"ppl":3.574,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":3.37,"ratio":1.06,"dcae":0.715,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5847,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Kiss+of+Death","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.081,"reach_vs_album":1.061,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.7336,"reach_pct":0.9185,"featuring":[],"isrc":null}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"dcb2536b-a011-33d3-b364-a4e724e5a7a8","art":true,"release_type":"album"},{"slug":"black-sabbath--13","artist":"Black Sabbath","title":"13","year":2013,"early":false,"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/13","min_listeners":25835,"gate_dcae":1.911,"leader":"Zeitgeist","evidence":"none","null_share":0.2618,"gate_pick":null,"naive_pick":"Zeitgeist","tracklist_source":"reference","first_release_date":"2013-06-07","list_sources":["crate:Black Sabbath"],"group":"crate","crate_artist":"Black Sabbath","is_ep":false,"is_mixtape":false,"album_listeners":308605,"album_listeners_ok":true,"album_listeners_spelling":"13","sleeper_hits":[{"name":"Zeitgeist","position":4,"listeners":143291,"singles_out_reached":1}],"depth":0.703,"least_reached":"Dear Father","grid":"ok","median_reach":0.4186,"median_ppl":4.4125,"cells":{"deep":1,"anthem":3,"passed":1,"rest":3},"deep_cut":null,"no_deep_cut":"None on this album: no non-single that qualifies has fewer listeners than the typical track and more plays each.","tracks":[{"position":1,"name":"End of the Beginning","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":486,"listeners":146461,"playcount":642479,"ppl":4.387,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.827,"ratio":0.909,"dcae":-1.485,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.4746,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/End+of+the+Beginning","cell":"passed","situation":"radio_single","ppl_vs_album":0.994,"reach_vs_album":1.134,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.8615,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302308"},{"position":2,"name":"God Is Dead?","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":532,"listeners":277950,"playcount":1564457,"ppl":5.629,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":5.159,"ratio":1.091,"dcae":1.352,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.9007,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/God+Is+Dead%3F","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.276,"reach_vs_album":2.152,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9803,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302420"},{"position":3,"name":"Loner","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":300,"listeners":172916,"playcount":798752,"ppl":4.619,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.763,"ratio":0.97,"dcae":-0.474,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.5603,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Loner","cell":"anthem","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":1.047,"reach_vs_album":1.339,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.9083,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302422"},{"position":4,"name":"Zeitgeist","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":278,"listeners":143291,"playcount":685265,"ppl":4.782,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.36,"ratio":1.097,"dcae":1.435,"is_leader":true,"is_cult":true,"reach_share":0.4643,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Zeitgeist","cell":"anthem","situation":"should_have_been_single","ppl_vs_album":1.084,"reach_vs_album":1.109,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.815,"reach_pct":0.8543,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302423"},{"position":5,"name":"Age of Reason","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":421,"listeners":115066,"playcount":510712,"ppl":4.438,"is_single":true,"single_kind":"official","is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":false,"expected_ppl":4.625,"ratio":0.96,"dcae":-0.639,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3729,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Age+of+Reason","cell":"deep","situation":"single_fans_kept","ppl_vs_album":1.006,"reach_vs_album":0.891,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":null,"reach_pct":0.7632,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302417"},{"position":6,"name":"Live Forever","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":287,"listeners":102132,"playcount":429099,"ppl":4.201,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.197,"ratio":1.001,"dcae":0.016,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3309,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Live+Forever","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.952,"reach_vs_album":0.79,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5335,"reach_pct":0.7019,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302421"},{"position":7,"name":"Damaged Soul","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":472,"listeners":98174,"playcount":426680,"ppl":4.346,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.276,"ratio":1.016,"dcae":0.253,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.3181,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Damaged+Soul","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.985,"reach_vs_album":0.76,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.5922,"reach_pct":0.6814,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302418"},{"position":8,"name":"Dear Father","artist":"Black Sabbath","album":"13","seconds":440,"listeners":89137,"playcount":364126,"ppl":4.085,"is_single":false,"single_kind":null,"is_interlude":false,"interlude_reason":null,"eligible":true,"expected_ppl":4.208,"ratio":0.971,"dcae":-0.459,"is_leader":false,"is_cult":false,"reach_share":0.2888,"shared_with":[],"lastfm_url":"https://www.last.fm/music/Black+Sabbath/_/Dear+Father","cell":"rest","situation":null,"ppl_vs_album":0.926,"reach_vs_album":0.69,"is_deep_cut":false,"ratio_pct":0.409,"reach_pct":0.6283,"featuring":[],"isrc":"GBUM71302419"}],"concentration":"shared","tier_pct":"notable","set":"ring4-01","mb_release_group":"5cbae3a0-6d55-497b-97b3-6c30a3264313","art":true,"release_type":"album"}]}